Cr Davidson RESOLVED that in view of a letter received from the applicant, the contents of the letter be noted and this item be withdrawn to allow a further report to be brought forward addressing the issues contained in the letter.
Voting - Unanimous
Cr Youngblutt RESOLVED that this item be deferred to allow representatives to address the Community Access session on 8 March 2000.
Current Status: Booked into Council's Community Access session on 8 March
2000.
1. Approves the submitted Development Application for the erection of a single storey dwelling subject to standard conditions
2. Approves the Special Licence for Placement of Moveable Dwelling for one (1) only moveable dwelling and associated cookhouse. Conditions of consent to include:-
i. The proposed permanent on-site sewage management system is to be installed and operational within two (2) months of approval.
ii. All domestic refuse wastes are to be disposed of through CouncilŐs Garbage Collection Service.
iii. The period of Special Licence is to be for twelve (12) months.
3. Commences proceedings in the Land and Environment Court against the Owner and/or occupier to remedy a breach of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act, including orders for demolition of two (2) of the three (3) tepees, and orders for costs.
Voting For
Cr Beck
Cr Lawrie
Voting Against
Cr Boyd
Cr Brinsmead
Cr Carroll
Cr Davidson
Cr James
Cr Luff
Cr Marshall
Cr Polglase
Cr Youngblutt
THE future of a small tepee village in the foothills of the Border Ranges remains
under a cloud despite a failed bid to ban all types of accommodation on the
property.
The Tweed Council last night voted 7-4 to defer action until residents
near the property at Chillingham had a chance to voice their objections.
About a dozen residents, who sat in the public gallery to hear the outcome,
welcomed the chance to speak out against the settlement.
Close neighbour Bernadette Barnes said the settlement boasted an Internet
site which indicated that up to 500 low-income people eventually couId live
there.
"The people living there now are really very nice but there will be a big
conflict between them and the activities of surrounding banana farmers if it
grows a lot bigger," she said.
Council staff had recommended the council take legal action to demolish
two tepees but allow a third to remain until an approved mud-brick house was
built.
Solicitor Gavin Lawrie sparked an angry debate when he moved for the
removal of all tepees and no approval for the house.
"Sooner or later we will haye an application to build a cubby house or
tree house - we are entitled to maintain standards," said Cr Lawrie.
Cr Lawrie's move - which would have effectively closed down the
settlement - failed after it won the support of only the Mayor, Lynne Beck.
A TWEED Shire Council debate on the future of teepees at an alternative community
in bushland at the back of the Tweed Valley last night led to claims of
discrimination against poor people.
Greens Party councillor Henry James accused some majority councillors of
having "one rule for the big boys in town and another for the very poorest".
He attacked a move by Cr Gavin Lawrie to order the demolition of three
teepees on the community near Chillingham and reject an application to build a
small house.
A group calling itself Dead Gum Revival Inc. sparked outrage in 1998 from
surrounding residents after it advertised plans for a low-income community
internationally on the Internet and built teepees without Council approval.
The Council. moved to prosecute the group under the Local Government Act
but environment and community services director, Don Buckley, revealed last night
that had not been done because a statute of limitations expired six months
after the teepees were built, possibly in May that year.
He recommended the Council now approve the proposed house with a 12-month
licence for one teepee, but prosecute the property owners for breaches of
environmental law and order demolition of another two teepees.
Cr Lawrie moved for the demolition of all three saying: "Sooner or later
we will have an application for approval of a cubbyhouse or treehouse to live in
but we are entitled to maintain standards."
"We don't have to put up with third world standards."
Liberal Party councillor Bronwynne Luff said the issue
epitomises the hatred towards people who don't have enough money to build big
stuff ".
And Cr Max Boyd said many people lived in sheds, garages and "all types
of structures around the Tweed but "discrimination is the operative word here".
Councillors voted to defer the matter until surrounding residents could
address them.
A PIONEER banana farmer, revered by alternative lifestylers, is to be
posthumously honoured while his "followers" are prosecuted.
The late Bryce Young has been hailed on the Internet as
a virtual guru of austere, non-material and peaceful lifestyle by a controversial
Tweed group which has set up a teepee village on his old farm at Chillingham.
Tweed Shire Councillors decided on Wednesday to prosecute the group for allegedly
erecting the teepees illegally.
But at the same meeting they voted to honour Mr Young, who died in October 1995,
by naming a public reserve after him.
The decision followed a request to Mayor Max Boyd in October from Mr Young's
nephew, the author of a report on the Internet and now the owner of the teepee
village property.
Brian Jefferies of
Newtown, Sydney, asked that 1.35 hectares transferred to the Council as part of a
subdivision of his uncle's estate in 1996 be named after Mr Young who was "a
widely respected member of the local community for nearly 50 years".
On a Web page set up to promote Dead Gum Revival's proposed ecologically
sustainable village on Mr Young's former property, Mr Jefferies has published an
address given at his uncle's wake which lightheartedly suggests: "In these
isolated valleys of the Tweed, it might even be possible to start off a Bryce
Young cult."
Mr Jefferies said Mr Young had "an inner peace, a calmness and a contempt for the
material world that Hindus and Buddhists aspire to."
"There probably aren't many people who would intentionally live in Bryce's
austere fashion. Our lives have become cluttered with the needs and desires
fostered by modern society's endless cycle of consumption and waste."
"By example, Bryce shows us that we needn't live that way; that the pursuit of
wealth, prestige, even rudimentary comfort, is ultimately without value."
"He lived the life he wanted to without much interference from authorities".
Those following in his path however now have to contend with legal action from
Tweed Shire Council over their erection of the controversial teepees.
A member of Dead Gum Revival, Kiri Sta, said the group was amazed at the
prosecution move but would continue to develop the land for an ecologically
sustainable village providing work, food and housing for low income and
unemployed people.
"It is beyond comprehension that an environmentally sustainable development
providing jobs and homes for people can be opposed by councillors," Ms Sta
said.
"Dead Gum Revival remains confident of resolving this issue because no one,
regardless of political persuasion, wants to see unemployment queues grow and
people made homeless."
"He would have done his own thing but he didn't bother anyone," the family friend
said. "I don't think he'd like to be embroiled in controversy."
THE operators of an alternative tepee village in the foothills of the Border
Ranges are to be prosecuted following a decision by Tweed Shire Council.
The move follows several complaints from Chillingham residents, west of
Murwillumbah, who claimed they were upset the operators of the community had not
sought council approval for the development.
But a spokeswoman for Dead Gum Revival Inc, who have advertised the alternative
wigwam world on the Internet, said after Wednesday night's council meeting her
group was the victim of 'small-town prejudice'.
"We don't believe we are doing anything wrong," said Kiri Sta.
"There is a lot of prejudice and in a shire with high unemployment they shouldn't
try to prosecute people who are trying to create employment.
"We are taking considerable steps so it doesn't turn into a drug den.
"We're not into people hanging out and smoking dope."
A council report on the secluded subdivision described the living conditions in
the three-tepee village as primitive but adequate.
"There does not appear to be any immediate elevated risk to the environment or
public health in the short term if adequate, management practises are observed,"
the report stated.
But 50 Chillingham locals, who packed the public gallery, said they were unhappy
the alternative entrepreneurs had not gone through the right processes before
developing the community.
"We're not happy they have developed this community without telling anyone," said
Chillingham resident Bernadette Barnes.
CHILLINGHAM residents have banded together to fight an ecologically sustainable
village that is being proposed by a group called Dead Gum Revival.
of discrimination
( ? 17/2/00)
alternative lifestylers
By PETER CATON ( Daily News 21/12/98)
By SCOTT DOWNMAN
( Gold Coast Bulletin
19/12/98)
( Tweed Link 15/12/98)
The spokesperson, Bernadette Barnes, said the organic permaculture village, proposed for 52ha, would be incompatible with the surrounding farms.
"It's located in the heart of our banana and cattle grazing area and such developments are usually incompatible with such intensive agriculture," she said. "We are concerned with issues such as loss of income, devaluation of our properties, sanitation and health, effect on infrastructure, privacy and impartiality of Council planning."
Prior to her address Dead Gum Revival member, Kiri Sta, told Council that the group would not object if their neighbours used chemical sprays.
She said Dead Gum Revival was dedicated to providing selfemployment for low income earners and had begun fruit and vegetable growing, poultry fanning, and some grazing of cattle.
In the future members hoped to move into larger scale cropping to provide feed for poultry, aquaculture and sheep and goat fanning. Council will next week consider whether it will take action regarding the teepees (which are not approved). And It will soon consider an application for a dwelling (to be used as a common house) and an application to use the teepees while this is being built. Applications have not yet been made for future stages of the community, as outlined on the Intemet.
The Internet promotion said up to 15 dwellings would be clustered in three sites and a resident artist's studio established.
It also said: "Residents of Gabalah should be sensitive to the needs of their neighbours to earn a living out of agriculture and to their historic connection to the area dating back from the original European settlement."
A GROUP of tepee dwellers in the hills behind Murwillumbah have appealled to their 'neighbours' to put aside their prejudices and accept them as new-wave pioneers.
Kiri Sta, a member of the fledgling community, told a Tweed Shire Council public access meeting that members were dedicated to providing self-employment for low-income workers.
"The early pioneers came here to exploit our rich timber resources but times have changed and we're a new sort of pioneer who are responsive to resource depletion," she said.
"Our community is a non-profit organisation dedicated to the environment and sustainable living, and the only way we can do this is to live and work on the land."
Ms Sta conceded up to four people were living in three tepees but the community --- Dead Gum revival Inc --- was seeking council approval to build a house to replace the illegal dwellings.
Her appeal follows growing disquiet among banana farmers surrounding the 53-hectare property at Chillingham who fear the growing commune may interfere with traditional farming practices.
Farmers' spokeswoman Bernadette Barnes said a meeting decided to oppose the settlement because stresses on existing roads and other infrastructure, potential sanitation problems and adverse impacts on property values. She said local residents were disturbed that the commune had set a web page on the Internet which contained information on ways groups can take councils to court, including case studies.
"We also believe that their plans to sustain themselves on the land is simply a pipedream," she told the access meeting on Wednesday.
AN alternative-lifestyle organisation which has built a teepee village in the Tweed hinterland says it has no council planning approval for the internationally advertised development.
The revelation came at Tweed Shire Council's community access session on Wednesday night attended by members of Dead Gum Revival Inc. and about 20 residents of the Chillingham district opposing the group's plans.
Dead Gum Revival spokesperson Kiri Sta told Mayor Max Boyd group members had no planning approval but had been living in teepees since May
The investigation followed complaints to Council from neighbours about "residential activities".
The teepees had allegedly been erected as temporary accommodation for an eco-village development advertised on the Internet.
The project, called "The Chillinghamlet", proposes to establish an economically sustainable village named Gabalah - an Aboriginal World for "scrub" - and involves revegetating the former pastoral property and nearby degraded land.
Spokesperson Kiri Sta said the group's intention had always been to gain Council approval for any permanent structures.
Protest committee spokesperson Bernadette Barnes told the access session Dead Gum Revival's plans for an environmentally and economically self-sustaining village for low-income people was a 'pipe-dream' set to fail and cause local problems.
Council officers are preparing a report on the development for next week's Council meeting following complaints about 'residential activities' including teepees on 52 hectares of old farmland off Hopkins Creek Road north of Chillingham.
Ms Sta told councillors the group's members were pioneers responding to resource depletion and providing opportunities for self-employment and housing to low-income people in the Tweed Shire.
Questioned by Cr Boyd she said the group had no planning approval but legal matters were involved and the community access session was "not an appropriate forum to go into depth on these legal issues"
Mrs Barnes told Wednesday's access session temporary dwellings had been occupied on the property for seven months. Local people believed stage two, involving a development application for a commonhouse was underway and would be followed by stage three involving multiple dwellings.
A GROUP which has allegedly set up a teepee village in the hills on the Queensland/ NSW border admits the development might be in a "grey area" of council regulations.
A spokesperson for Dead Gum Revival Inc. said the group intended to gain Council approval for any permanent structures but for the time being it was necessary for members of the group to be living and working on the land.
Last week it was revealed Tweed Shire Council had launched an investigation into reports that the teepee village had been set up on 50 hectares of old farmland near Chillingham.
The investigation followed complaints to Council from neighbours about "residential activities".
The teepees had allegedly been erected as temporary accommodation for an eco-village development advertised on the Internet.
The project, called "The Chillinghamlet", proposes to establish an economically sustainable village named Gabalah - an Aboriginal World for "scrub" - and involves revegetating the former pastoral property and nearby degraded land.
Spokesperson Kiri Sta said the group's intention had always been to gain Council approval for any permanent structures.
"We are currently working towards this with Council staff who have been most helpful," she said.
"The progressive nature of this development means we are often in 'grey areas' of current regulations".
Ms Sta said the group believed it had a good relationship with the majority of Chillingham district residents.
She said members were willing to discuss their activities but had not been approached.
REPORTS that a teepee village has been set up in hills near the
Queensland/NSW border at the back of the Tweed Valley have sparked an
investigation by Tweed Shire Council.
Council officials yesterday
confirmed a report would be prepared for councillors following a number of
complaints about "residential activities" on 50 hectares of old farmland near
Chillingham.
The teepees have allegedly been erected as temporary
accommodation for an eco-village development advertised on the Internet.
The project called 'The Chillinghamlet" on the Internet proposes a economically
sustainable village named Gabalah - an Aboriginal world
for "scrub".
It is the brainchild of a group calling itself Dead Gum
Revival Inc. which wants to revegetate the former pastoral property and nearby
degraded land.
But no development application for the project has been
approved by the Council and surrounding residents have complained the "alternate
lifestylers" appear to "know exactly how to get around Council regulations".
Local people have said they are not only concerned at an alternate village
springing up in the neighbourhood but upset it had been advertised
internationally on the Web before locals were consulted.
Yesterday
little could be seen from the entrance of Hopkins Creek Road except for signs
warning the property was private and no unauthorised entry allowed.
Attempts to contact one of the residents were unsuccessful.
The
Councils's acting environment and community services director Rick Paterson said
complaints were being investigated and officers were looking closely at "sanitary
matters" and a range of other issues.
It is understood officers have
concluded no applications for building teepees were necessary because they are
not permanent structures but are investigating if they can be classed as mobile
dwellings.
The "Chillinghamlet" web page says: "Multiple Occupancy
entitlement will be sought once we are living in temporary accommodation on the
land."
Cr Lynne Beck said she had been unable to get answers from the
Council to complaints about activities on the property
Last week Cr Bob
Brinsmead complained the Council was not being consistent, with prosecutions of
people for illegal building after councillors voted 8-to-3 to take legal action
against a developer for erecting a shed without the necessary approval.
He said Tweed had "illegal hamlets" but the Council insisted on taking a
developer "to the cleaners for a technical breach".
The Council was told
that a brick shed housing a pump used to aerate a man-made lake at the Noble Lake
Mobile Home Park, at Chinderah, had been erected without Council approval.
A neighbour had complained about the noise of the pump and said the shed
interrupted their views of the lake and the mountains beyond.
PROPOSALS for a self-sufficient "eco-village" for unemployed and low-income people on the Tweed are making their way into cyberspace. One web-site on the Internet has already been launched by a Sydney university academic supporting plans for a "hamlet style development" on 51 hectares of degraded pastoral land near Chillingham. And another group which hopes to get unemployed people off the dole with its plan is about to set up a comprehensive web-site seeking public input. Actor, Robin Harrison, spokesman for the Tweed EcoVillage project which began nearly three years ago, said the idea had spawned interest in similar schemes around the Tweed Valley He said various parcels of land had become available and several groups including his own were developing detailed plans. One group which has already put a concept plan on the Internet is Dead Gum Revival Inc., a team of people including a University of New South Wales mathematics professor interested in revegetating dying bushland. On its web page "The Chillinghamlet", the group says members have obtained a six year lease on a Chillingham property formerly- owned by farmer, academic and steam-locomotion enthusiast Bryce Young who died in 1995. The group plans "basic shelter" as stage one, a community house as stage two and a multiple occupancy hamlet as stage three. The development would be called "Gabalah" - a local Aboriginal word for scrub. It would consist of "low cost, low impact satellite dwellings" and an "indigenous artists studio" linked with a Brisbane art gallery. The land is in Hopkins Creek Road, two kilometres from the Chillingham General Store and according to the group would support a bio-dynamic market garden, a food forest, orchards, herb gardens, free ranging poultry and aquaculture. Meanwhile Mr Harrison says his group has looked at various parcels of land and is continuing to refine plans using "a wealth of like minds". Tweed Shire Council development control manager Garry Smith said he was unaware of the Gabalah plans but had talked with members of the Tweed Eco-Village group.